Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Your post does not really do much to dispel the negative picture that the opening article paints of you. You say their decline is "predominantly an industry problem". Is this also the case for your own company, Formation? You went on the record comparing Codesmith to a sex cult and accusing it of deceiving and exploiting its students and evidently consider criticising them to be a mission worth years of near-daily dedication, and the only example you have to offer to justify this in a thread where people question your motives for this is... some random anecdote about them having an IT fuckup?

This doesn't read as if you have a coherent case that Codesmith is bad to an extent that justifies your single-minded effort to spread this message, but as either an attempt to throw more FUD at the wall in the hope that something sticks even in this forum, or an indication that you are not quite well.



I compared the statement 'do this because it changed my life and the life of many others' to the type of language used in cult documentaries on HBO. I stand by that opinion.

Codesmith is not a sex cult. I can't believe I'm writing that sentence.


There were any number of less pejorative comparisons you could have made if that was all you wanted to say. I regularly see grandiose claims of life-changing benefits on everything ranging from mildly pointless and overpriced meditation retreats down to Toastmasters, and yet you chose the one entity whose main claim to publicity were things that got its leader-guru sentenced to 120 years in a max security prison.


> I compared the statement 'do this because it changed my life and the life of many others' to the type of language used in cult documentaries on HBO

why did you make that comparison?


Because the person was making an argument to go to Codesmith that sounded like the reasons people sold low-confident individuals into joining cults.

These are the reasons I TOLD PEOPLE TO GO TO CODESMITH PRIOR TO 2024: if you were extremely ambitious, successful in your previous job, a good communicator, and had a natural affinity to coding.


It's fine to participate in the thread and present your version of events, but we need you to observe the guidelines, which ask us to avoid fulmination and using capitalisation for emphasis.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Thanks for letting me know that, I didn't know


What happened in 2024 that changed your mind?


This: https://web.archive.org/web/20240418095904/https://www.codes...

I paused my recommendation to wait to see if they did what they said they would do. In my opinion they did not, so I then removed my recommendation.


Wait, so you went on a year plus long, single person crusade against a company because.....they offered remote learning options?

That's the straw that broke the camels back? What a weird thing to decide to destroy a company over.


> I compared the statement 'do this because it changed my life and the life of many others' to the type of language used in cult documentaries on HBO. I stand by that opinion.

This is ludicrous ... it's also the type of language used by all sorts of people in all sorts of situations. Mentioning a cult is the least charitable thing that can be said.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: